Jump to content

Searching For An Asscher, Opinions


Recommended Posts

I am putting together a ring for my girlfriend of two years. She loves the asscher cut, so I think I want to go with this one:




What do you think? My main concerns were the shallow depth and the polish and symmetry rating of good. The setting will be custom, based on a royal asscher model. It will likely be platinum.


WEIGHT: 0.53ct

SHAPE: Asscher Cut



MEASUREMENTS: 4.81 x 4.69 x 2.96 mm






GIA REPORT #: 15539675


The site just says it has an amazing cut, but don't see a cut rating. What are your impressions from what you can see? Thanks for the advice!

Edited by suneohair
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...



1. There is no GIA cut grading for Asscher (or as they would call them square emerald or square step) cut diamonds.

2. A depth of 63% is well within the range of acceptability - many (e.g. AGA guidelines) would qualify this as excellent/ideal.

3. A depth of 63% means the stone faces up relatively large for a 0.53 ct.

4. The differences between good and very good or excellent polish and simmetry are very unlikely to be seen with the naked eye

5. D/IF stones are not easy to find. Small D/IF Asscher cut diamonds are durned difficult to find. Well cut small D/IF Asscher cut... - OK, I think you understand where I'm going




1. I like the stone, based on the pictures, the movie, and the GIA grade

2. I think it's well cut, with a well-defined step pattern and large windmills/corners

3. I trust David's opinion and honesty. He likes this stone, and I have never been unhappy with his choices.

4. I find the price a little steep; not so much for what it is (though it ain't a bargain), but given that for a little more money I could get a well cut 1.something H/VS which you'd have a tough time to pick from a 0.53% D/IF once set - except that it faces 60% bigger :)

5. If it had been a little cheaper, I would have probably bought it already. :)




ETA: adjusted layout

Edited by davidelevi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Numbers are totally meaningless when it comes fancy cuts. Advising that certain numbers are "acceptable" and within an "acceptable" range does not assist in making a purchase decision because two fancy cuts diamonds can have the same exact "numbers" and face up completely different.


A skilled diamond cutter can fashion a beautiful face up stone with "numbers" that don't fit into an arbitrary scale.


The benefit to a prospective purchaser here is the photo, video, reputable and knowledgable diamantaire selling this merchandise, and clearly spelled out Return Policy if you're not satisified.


Insofar as pricing, D/IF is rare. Only you can decide if you want a higher carat weight/ lower color-clarity combination.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...