Got Diamond Questions?
Our community of diamond experts are here to provide answers
Sign in to follow this  
jigote

Help With Quality

Recommended Posts

Good Morning.

I want to buy some earrings with diamonds, I'm not an expert, and they offer me three difentes. All of around 0.5 carats (each slope). And I do not know which is better. O What is seen (in view of not expert) plus the failure.

1
Main Stone Creation: Natural
Main Stone: Diamond
Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced
Clarity: SI1
Main Stone Color: White
Theme: Beauty
Cut: Very Good
Country / Region of Manufacture: United States
Main Stone Shape: Round


2
Transparency: I1
Size: Excellent
Style: Tacha
Color of the diamonds: E
Main Stone Treatment: Not Improved
  Purity of the metal: 1.01
Main Stone Creation: Natural
Shape of the main stone: Round

3
Style: Stud
Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond
Color: D
Clarity: VS2
Cut: Very Good Main Stone
Shape: Round


THANK YOU
 
 
 
 
 
Sugerir un cambio
Ver traducción original
 
Tu contribución se utilizará para mejorar la calidad de la traducción y podría mostrarse a los usuarios de forma anónima.
Enviar
Cerrar
 
Buenos días. Quiero comprar unos pendientes con diamantes, no soy experto, y me ofrecen tres difentes. Todos de alrededor de 0.5 kilates (cada pendiente). Y no sé cual es mejor. O Cual se ve (a vista de no experto) más el fallo. Main Stone Creation: Natural Main Stone: Diamond Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced Clarity: SI1 Main Stone Colour: White Theme: Beauty Cut: Very Good Country/Region of Manufacture: United States Main Stone Shape: Round Transparencia: I1 Talla: Excelente Estilo: Tacha Color de los diamantes: E Tratamiento de Piedra Principal: No Mejorado Pureza del metal: 1.01 Piedra Principal Creation: Natural Forma de la piedra principal: Redondo Style: Stud Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond Colour: D Clarity: VS2 Cut: Very Good Main Stone Shape: Round GRACIAS
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Definiciones de Buenos días. Quiero comprar unos pendientes con diamantes, no soy experto, y me ofrecen tres difentes. Todos de alrededor de 0.5 kilates (cada pendiente). Y no sé cual es mejor. O Cual se ve (a vista de no experto) más el fallo. Main Stone Creation: Natural Main Stone: Diamond Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced Clarity: SI1 Main Stone Colour: White Theme: Beauty Cut: Very Good Country/Region of Manufacture: United States Main Stone Shape: Round Transparencia: I1 Talla: Excelente Estilo: Tacha Color de los diamantes: E Tratamiento de Piedra Principal: No Mejorado Pureza del metal: 1.01 Piedra Principal Creation: Natural Forma de la piedra principal: Redondo Style: Stud Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond Colour: D Clarity: VS2 Cut: Very Good Main Stone Shape: Round GRACIAS
 
 
 
Sinónimos de Buenos días. Quiero comprar unos pendientes con diamantes, no soy experto, y me ofrecen tres difentes. Todos de alrededor de 0.5 kilates (cada pendiente). Y no sé cual es mejor. O Cual se ve (a vista de no experto) más el fallo. Main Stone Creation: Natural Main Stone: Diamond Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced Clarity: SI1 Main Stone Colour: White Theme: Beauty Cut: Very Good Country/Region of Manufacture: United States Main Stone Shape: Round Transparencia: I1 Talla: Excelente Estilo: Tacha Color de los diamantes: E Tratamiento de Piedra Principal: No Mejorado Pureza del metal: 1.01 Piedra Principal Creation: Natural Forma de la piedra principal: Redondo Style: Stud Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond Colour: D Clarity: VS2 Cut: Very Good Main Stone Shape: Round GRACIAS
 
 
 
Ejemplos de Buenos días. Quiero comprar unos pendientes con diamantes, no soy experto, y me ofrecen tres difentes. Todos de alrededor de 0.5 kilates (cada pendiente). Y no sé cual es mejor. O Cual se ve (a vista de no experto) más el fallo. Main Stone Creation: Natural Main Stone: Diamond Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced Clarity: SI1 Main Stone Colour: White Theme: Beauty Cut: Very Good Country/Region of Manufacture: United States Main Stone Shape: Round Transparencia: I1 Talla: Excelente Estilo: Tacha Color de los diamantes: E Tratamiento de Piedra Principal: No Mejorado Pureza del metal: 1.01 Piedra Principal Creation: Natural Forma de la piedra principal: Redondo Style: Stud Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond Colour: D Clarity: VS2 Cut: Very Good Main Stone Shape: Round GRACIAS
 
 
 
Ver también
 
 
 
 
Traducciones de Buenos días. Quiero comprar unos pendientes con diamantes, no soy experto, y me ofrecen tres difentes. Todos de alrededor de 0.5 kilates (cada pendiente). Y no sé cual es mejor. O Cual se ve (a vista de no experto) más el fallo. Main Stone Creation: Natural Main Stone: Diamond Main Stone Treatment: Clarity Enhanced Clarity: SI1 Main Stone Colour: White Theme: Beauty Cut: Very Good Country/Region of Manufacture: United States Main Stone Shape: Round Transparencia: I1 Talla: Excelente Estilo: Tacha Color de los diamantes: E Tratamiento de Piedra Principal: No Mejorado Pureza del metal: 1.01 Piedra Principal Creation: Natural Forma de la piedra principal: Redondo Style: Stud Main Stone Treatment: Filling Diamond Colour: D Clarity: VS2 Cut: Very Good Main Stone Shape: Round GRACIAS
 
 
 
 
Arrastra y suelta el archivo o enlace aquí para traducir el documento o la página web.
Arrastra y suelta el enlace aquí para traducir la página web.
El tipo de archivo que has soltado no es compatible. Inténtalo con otro tipo de archivo.
El tipo de enlace que has soltado no es compatible. Inténtalo con otro tipo de enlace.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I"m afraid we may be either losing a great deal in translation or you simply don't have enough information to make even a random guess (or both)

Do you know what clarity enhanced means?  You should look this up.  It's important. 

Also important is who supplied all of this data and what criteria were they using. 

Edited by denverappraiser

Neil Beaty

GG(GIA) ICGA(AGS) NAJA

 

There's never a crowd when you go that extra mile.

Professional Appraisals in Denver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good morning again.

Sorry for the translation.

The issue is that I want to buy some pendisntes and I have a low budget. They offer me three different diamonds and I would like to know which ones look better to the human eye of an inexperienced person.

The first ones are untreated with clarity I1 and color E.

The seconds are with Clarity Enhanced treatment (I do not know exactly which), Clarity Si1 and color H.

The last ones are treated with Diamond Filling, VS2 clarity and D color.


With these data, and knowing the difficulty involved in the decision with the data that I explain. Which would be more beautiful visually? I as inexperienced and normal view (without a microscope), would notice the difference?

THANK YOU VERY MUCH

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BTW - pendientes = earrings, not pendants. This may help you searching for more relevant sites!

The problem, as Neil said, is that there really isn't enough information to help you decide or us to provide you with advice.

Personally I don't like clarity enhanced (which is usually the same thing as "filled")  stones, but they have their market, and that would leave one pair only, but I1 can be a significant risk in terms of visibility of the inclusions.

Also, again as Neil said, who is calling the diamonds D, E  or H colour and I1 clarity (clarity grades on enhanced stones are dubious at best: is it clarity "before the filling"? "after the filling"? "excluding the filling"? - that's one reason why reliable labs do NOT grade CE stones).

Let me work from another angle: assuming that you are looking for a pair of stud earrings, about 0.5 ct total weight, how much do you want to spend?


Davide - Specialised Consumer Information and Assistance,
Diamonds by Lauren (http://www.diamondsbylauren.com)
davide@diamondsbylauren.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You want to know what looks best to the human eye but there are no human eyes involved. Have you seen them? Could you tell the difference?

Claims of clarity on filled stones are, at best, unsupported and at worst complete baloney. There is no scale. GIA grades (like VS2) don’t apply to these stones.  Color is a matter of skills and methodology of the grader. It’s not that they are wrong, it’s just that we don’t know anything at all.  “Some guy said it was a F”.  Great. Who? The untreated I-1 has the same problem. I-1 according to whom? There are a few things you included that are completely out in space like “Theme: beauty or Style: Tasha”.  I have no idea what those mean or if you would like them.  There’s simply no way to say if Tasha style is better than something else without knowing what they’re even talking about.  You didn’t give prices and you only gave weight as around 0.50 each or maybe 0.50 total weight. I"m not sure because of the translation. We know nothing at all about the mountings other than that they’re earrings. This all leaves an enormous range and anything like a straight answer would be doing you a disservice.

 


Neil Beaty

GG(GIA) ICGA(AGS) NAJA

 

There's never a crowd when you go that extra mile.

Professional Appraisals in Denver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re-reading the Spanish above, it's ~0.50 ct each. It solves nothing in terms of the open questions, but at least that part is clear.

@jigote - the problem is that there isn't any data on which to help you with. Your question at the moment is a bit like someone asking:

"Of the following three cars, which one is fastest?

1. Has two doors and is red.
2. Has four doors and is blue.
3. Has two doors and is silver." 


Davide - Specialised Consumer Information and Assistance,
Diamonds by Lauren (http://www.diamondsbylauren.com)
davide@diamondsbylauren.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this