Looking for your suggestion on the following two diamonds for Harry Winston engagement ring.
D color rating
VS1 clarity, with a few crystal, cloud and pinpoint at the edge
Table size 58%
F color rating
VVS2 clarity, with 3 pinpoints near the center
Table size 61%
Both diamonds have excellent cuts, symmetry, and no fluorescence. Diamond 1 is $7,000 more expensive than Diamond 2.
My questions are:
Is 61% table size considered too much for light leakage?
Is the $7,000 price difference well justified by the difference in quality of the two diamonds?
How would you choose between these two diamonds? Why?
I've attached reports for both diamonds. Thank you for your help on this!