A-List Appraiser
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

471 Excellent

About denverappraiser

  • Rank
    Ideal Diamond

Profile Information

  • Gender
  • Location
    Denver Colorado, USA

Recent Profile Visitors

9150 profile views
  1. denverappraiser

    Edwin Novel

  2. denverappraiser

    Edwin Novel

    I share your skepticism of reviews and Google but I’m even more skeptical on unknown review sites like, the one they’re using. I’m not going to comment either way on a piece I haven’t seen but I’m curious, what we’re your filter criteria that led to this?
  3. denverappraiser

    Opinions wanted on ASET and IdealScope blue Asscher images

    Yes, it matters. Fancy colored diamonds are cut to maximize color as well as light return. Normally they want to have the longest light path through the stone possible. In traditional colorless stones, they want the shortest path.
  4. denverappraiser

    Please help me pick the better ACA

    The heart of this is the balance between weight, clarity, color, and price. Not so much cutting. G/SI1s generally cost more than otherwise similar I/VS2s. Heavier stones generally cost more than lighter ones. The reason they’re recommending the G/SI1 is that all things being equal, it’s a better ‘deal’. When you shop it, which I assume you’ve done, the dealer comes out looking better in comparison to other dealers with similar goods. The missing element is YOU. Do you prefer G to I or would you prefer something slightly bigger for less money? That’s about taste, not gemology. If you haven’t seen what real diamonds look like, go shopping. Maybe even go to Houston and look at Whiteflash. They have a showroom there. (Note: If you do this, make an appointment and let them know what you expect to see. Not all or even most stones on the website are in the store). Most jewelers don't bite and there's no obligation to buy. Tell them what you're thinking, ask to see what they have, and pay attention to what they have to say.
  5. denverappraiser

    Uniqueness of diamonds

    The weakness is in the value chain. The miner knows where they found each stone. Also when, what tools and techniques they were using, which workers were involved, what part of the mine and all sorts of other details. Not tracking these things would just be bad management. The same happens at the cutter. They know what they paid, where and when they bought it, who worked on it, what results they expected and how it worked out. Anything less would just be stupid. They know who they sold it to, when, and for how much. The whole supply chain looks like this. It’s not that the data isn’t there, it’s that they don’t want to pass it along for any reason short of a court order. Why not? Money. A lot of this is proprietary information, it’s extra work and extra exposure to track it, and there’s no extra money for those who do it. Customers claim they want to know, but when it comes time to pay, they’re happy enough without it. They want it if it’s free. Yeah, right. That’s why I’m suspicious of these blockchain type claims. What the blockchain adds to the program is to protect the data from tampering. That’s interesting, and possibly even useful, but it's solving a problem that no one has.
  6. denverappraiser

    Uniqueness of diamonds is offering exactly this service for approximately that reason. They are a large and well established company in the industry. Mine to finger provenance. It’s the underlying technology for the everledger people If you want to make even a remotely scholarly paper, make you understand the concept of ‘blood diamonds’. That’s a PR term that doesn’t mean what people tend to expect. Blockchain is designed to make it difficult to alter records. It does that quite well and it’s a darling for investors. Anything with the word ‘blockchain’ in it is a topic of discussion. That doesn’t make the underlying data valid, useful, or even true. The problem, and the solution, of so-called blood diamonds mostly has to do with do with local power in the source countries. Everledger doesn’t have anything to do with that. What they do is connect the word blockchain to diamonds, and that’s an advertising opportunity in the west. That has merit, but it doesn’t sound like what you’re looking into.
  7. denverappraiser

    A diamond trapped in glass

    From their advertisement: “Working with a unique hybrid form of glass that is resistant to acid, heat, and bubble formation, Diamonds in Glass® artisans use a proprietary technology to create a perfect globe housing a single magnificent diamond in virtually unbreakable glass. The special glass magnifies the brilliance, scintillation, and sparkle of the diamond so that it appears triple its dimension." This is a little heavy on the techno-babble for my taste, but there's nothing fundamentally wrong with it. I see no reason to think it's not possible with the right glass recipe and the right tools. FWIW, it does look difficult but the key is in that 'proprietary technology', i.e. the right tools. I think most GS inspections involve a laser inscription on the stone that you should be able to see through the glass under magnification. This could be done on a fake too, but as Davide points out above, it's quite a chore to fake a stone that wouldn't be all that expensive anyway. Is there some reason you're suspecting shenanigans?
  8. denverappraiser

    Worst Experience Ever

    Maybe he meant that New York was too shady. Perhaps it's all the concrete. I must say, I have problems with that. I like the sun.
  9. denverappraiser

    Help with heart shaped ASET

    The paycheck for affiliates comes from directing you towards particular sellers. They may find the same stone, they may find one that’s better (or cheaper), or they may lead you to something else entirely. There’s nothing specifically wrong with any of that but bear in mind that we’re talking about commission sales people. Take their advice accordingly.
  10. denverappraiser

    Help with heart shaped ASET

    I rather like the black backgrounds but it does take a little bit of practice to interpret them. From my world (I’m an appraiser), the advantage is that you can replicate them with a mounted stone and you can’t with the white background ones. I do find them useful, just not for evaluating fire as you requested. In any case, I agree with Davide that it’s not for the same stone so it doesn’t matter a bit.
  11. denverappraiser

    How can i get best custom Jewelry manufacturing service in us?

    Welcome to DiamondReview. Every custom jeweler on the planet could make either of those, as I'm sure you know. Neither is especially difficult. That begs the question of what you mean by 'best', no matter how good you are. Cheapest? Fastest? Highest quality? Given that you're a jeweler, I presume the idea here is that it's you. I"ve never heard of you, which means nothing by the way, and don't even know where your store is, but it strikes me as highly unlikely that you would match most definitions of 'best'. That's not a criticism of your store, it's simply an impossible standard. What then is the point of this post? I"m going to take a guess. You're trying to promote the store. Believe it or not, I"m a big fan of that (promotion), but allow me to suggest you work a little harder at it. Sign up as a jeweler if you haven't already (it's free). Then read people's questions and provide useful and accurate answers. People will read your advice, not just the original poster, notice the link at the bottom of your page back to your store, and buy things from you. You've already established your credibility. Repeat. You'll be amazed how well it works and you'll be amazed at how much YOU learn both by knowing what people are asking and by reading the advice given by others. It WILL make you a better jeweler. By the way, read the rules. There's a link at the bottom of the page. You've already violated them by posting as a jeweler in the 'classified' section of the site. That's specifically reserved for individual sellers.
  12. denverappraiser

    Review of HRD 1.02ct F VVS2 3x VG

    I totally believe it's a nice stone. I'm criticizing the grading scale, not your diamond. The problem with the cut scale is this: Here's the whole scale: Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor That makes VG look pretty good, it’s just below the best and it's usually reflected in the price, but look from the other end. Just try and find a poor, fair, or even a good. I’ll wait. Using the diamondfinder as broadly as I can, there are 524,000 round stones listed at the moment. 18,000 are Good and 1508 are Fair. None are Poor. The bottom 3 grades combined are only 3%! VG has 346,000, a little over half, but when I limit it to VG VG(or worse) symmetry and polish it drops all the way to 21,000. 94% are better on paper than that! That’s not an entirely fair test, some VG VG VGs are pretty darned good, and sometimes the issues are more subtle than those polish and symmetry grades indicate, but seeing it as almost the top is a serious misunderstanding of the scale.
  13. denverappraiser

    Review of HRD 1.02ct F VVS2 3x VG

    HRD is a reliable enough lab but I’m curious how you picked this particular stone. High clarity(VVS2), high color(F), low cutting (VG, VG, VG) is an unusual combination. Did you pick this or was it the dealer selling it? There are 481 superficially comparable stones in the diamondfinder database here, for example. 440 of them are graded as better cut than this one (as mentioned by Laurent above, they may have other issues that come into play but cutting seems to be your question given what you've told us about the stone.)
  14. denverappraiser

    on the hunt for the perfect emerald

    I just noticed that contact information is no longer in the footers. Hmm. There seems to be no way to know who you're talking to. Davide is: Mine is
  15. denverappraiser

    on the hunt for the perfect emerald

    The tax benefit goes away if you report things to customs, and if you don’t report, you have the potential for other problems. It is possible, and people do it all the time, but it is illegal. Just sayin’. Davide works for a jeweler in NYC. He’s too polite to plug himself but there are links in the signature block at the bottom of every one of his posts. Who is ‘best’ will depend to a large degree on what you want. For example, I’ve linked above 399 stones that meet your requirements. There’s obviously a pricing question that’s going to come up but, in practice, most of those stones will be available at any jeweler you want. I’m not an uninvolved observer either (I’m an appraiser), but what I look for in a jeweler is pretty straightforward: 1) The truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. If you get a feeling that they’re hiding things or filtering details based on criteria other than yours, move on. 2) They know. There are a shocking number of uneducated jewelers out there. It continuously amazes me how many think there’s nothing important beyond what appears on the GIA reports. Not everyone knows everything and it’s fair for them to do research, but if you get a feeling that they don’t know and just don’t care, move on. By the way, don’t be shocked if they ask for a deposit. It costs money to bring in stones to show you and it takes time to talk to you. They deserve to be paid. 3) Terms and conditions vary and they get difficult in your price range. Mostly it’s not about credit cards for example. Read the T&C carefully. Plan on getting it appraised by an independent appraiser (not their guy and not a competitive seller) and you should have the right to return it if this goes badly. This often causes stress with sellers on expensive items and there is often time pressure. Compare their answers to this question. 4) You haven’t answered the questions of your objectives and what that swirl ring has to do with it, but that’s not an easy job. Not everyone is prepared to make that and not everyone will tell you if it’s outside their skill set. That may or may not matter to where you buy the diamond but that’s a complicated job. Look at their work. You’re fishing for talent over price here. 5) Search their reputations, both online and with friends. If they don’t have any footprints, move on. As you point out, there are a lot of jewelers out there. To your other question. Your cell phone (a rectangle with blunted corners) and a stop sign (an octagon) are both emerald cuts. The look is very different. Most ECs have 4 pavilion mains. That’s the A few have 5 or even 6, some have only 3. It’s not that one is better than the other, or even more expensive, it’s that they’re different. Do you have a preference? If you don’t even know the question, you’ll never know the answer, and the way you get these questions is from talking to the salespeople and by looking at stones.